Skip to main content

Much Ado About Nothing: “They who love believe easily in love”

So says Dumas in his brilliant novel – The Three Musketeers. I couldn't help thinking about that when I read Much Ado About Nothing. I sincerely think that it's very funny how people could do foolish things in love.

When the prince decided to deceive both Benedick and Beatrice into loving each others, he might not have thought that they were in love with each other already. But I feel that those two were already in love with each other – consciously or unconsciously.

Ladies first, that is, Beatrice. What is her first line in all the play? “Is Signior Mountanto return'd from the wars, or no?” Who is Signior Mountanto? Well, Benedick. The first thing that this lady asked, knowing that Don Pedro was coming, is about Benedick. Out of scorn? Well, may be, may be not. On Don Pedro and his friends' arrival, to whom did Beatrice speak first? Aha, Benedick! Don Pedro, Claudio and all other people didn't matter. She has a thing for Benedick. What's that thing? Enmity? I think more than that.

In the next act, Leonato was talking about Don John, which he thought so grim and melancholy. Beatrice agreed, and compared him, not his brother, who was, in my opinion, a good gentleman, kind and funny, a well-balanced person. No, Beatrice instead compared him to Benedick. And then she said this line, “With a good leg and a good foot, uncle, and money enough in his purse, such man could win any woman in the world, - if he could get her good will.” Now I know it sounds like scorn. But it means that she doesn't at all despise the idea of Benedick as a husband.

That sentence from her resembles so much Benedick's view of her. When Claudio stated that Hero was the most beautiful thing his eyes ever looked upon, Benedick said this, “There's her cousin, an' she were not possessed with a fury, exceeds her as much in beauty as the first of May doth the last of December.” A-ha! Conclusion: In Benedick's eyes, Beatrice is far more beautiful than Hero as much as summer is compared to winter. Of course he had to add, “if she were not possessed with a fury” to make it plain that he didn't like her. Or did he?

Well, what makes me pretty sure that it indicates that they had crush on each other is the fact that I had done the trick several times. I don't know if people in Shakespeare's time did the same, but the art of love doesn't change so much since the beginning of the world, right? 

When the prince was resolved to be a matchmaker and deceived Beatrice and Benedick into confessing their love to each other, it wasn't a Hercules' labour, at least not that hard. As quoted above, Dumas, in his romance The Three Musketeers says, “They who love believe easily in love.” Thus those two, having loved each other, in mask of scorn or in the secret corners of their mind, readily believe that the other party loved as well. Haha. That's actually funny. 


Popular posts from this blog

Problems with Translating Shakespeare

I've found several articles regarding this on the net. I'm new to the Shakespeare world, therefore I didn't know much about the translation issue.

In the net, there are "study guides" for Shakespeare, such as No Fear Shakespeare which provides students with modern English translation of William Shakespeare. I bet students will find it highly useful, especially those who are not well-acquainted with plays or old classical literatures or writings in verse. Apart from that, I am also aware that there are modern English editions of Shakespeare available in book stores. (I know that accidentally, because I found some quotes on Goodreads which convey Shakespeare's ideas but not in his exact words.)

On the other hand, there are people like David Crystal, which I highly respect (truly I love everything he says about Shakespeare's words and also original pronunciation), who insists that no translation is needed in understanding Shakespeare. There is even a debate …

Henry V: Self-Punishment on the Death of Bardolph

Prince Hal, and later, the king, Henry V is a complex character with volumes to think, say, and analyse about. Following his character development from Henry IV part 1 through Henry V, it's hard not to relate to him when one comes to what people call 'conflict of interests.'

For me, the worst part of it in Henry V is when he heard that his (former) friend, Bardolph, had been executed for thievery. In many productions, the directors let Henry either see the execution, or at least the hanged man. Kenneth Branagh and Hollow Crown versions even take time for a little flashback, therefore show us that the king remembered Bardolph and all things they had done together in their former days. Both also, through acting, show that the king was sad about it, yet could do nothing.

Reading the play, however, it was quite shocking that the king made no comment upon the hanging, except that it was just and necessary.

Why didn't he say anything about it? Knowing Shakespeare, he could h…

Say It Like Shakespeare: No Make-Up Day

Ada saat-saat di mana kita sebagai perempuan malas banget pakai make-up. Buat saya, itu mood sehari-hari. Mungkin ada lah beberapa hari dalam setahun di mana jiwa perempuan normal dalam diri saya ingin menunjukkan sisi femininnya, tapi selain itu..

Karena itu hari ini saya ingin berbagi beberapa quote Shakespeare yang sering muncul di kepala saya kalau saya sudah mulai disuruh dandan.
Henry IV, Part I Waktu mikirin soal bagaimana bayak orang mengkritik gaya hidup dia yang sama sekali nggak kaya pangeran yang bakal memimpin kerajaan suatu hari nanti.

If all the year were playing holidays,
To sport would be as tedious as to work;
But when they seldom come, they wished-for come,
And nothing pleaseth but rare accidents.
Yang artinya,

Kalau sepanjang tahun libur terus, libur bakal sama ngeboseninnya kaya hari kerja. Tapi ketika kita jarang libur, liburan jadi hal yang ditunggu-tunggu. Nggak ada yang lebih menyenangkan daripada hal yang jarang terjadi. 
Yang buat saya artinya: kalo terlalu ser…